Convert Criticism into a Commitment and a Request: A Path to Constructive Communication

November 17, 2023

Embracing Positive Change Through Language

Transforming Criticism into Constructive Feedback

In the journey of leadership and personal growth, the way we express our thoughts and concerns holds immense power. The words we choose can either build bridges or erect walls. Two insightful authors, Lisa Laskow Lahey and Robert Keegan in “Immunity to Change,” and Charlie Pellerin in “How NASA Builds Teams,” offer transformative approaches to convert criticism into something more constructive: commitment and requests.

1. Transforming Criticism into Commitment

Lahey and Keegan propose a radical shift in perspective. They argue that criticism is often a veiled form of commitment expressed negatively. This idea resonates deeply with the ethos of transformation and growth. Rather than focusing on what is wrong, this approach encourages us to articulate what we are genuinely committed to achieving.

For instance, criticizing government inefficiency can be reframed as a commitment to fostering effective governance. Similarly, instead of pointing out the shortcomings in a marketing manager’s performance, we can express our commitment to a team that consistently meets its objectives. This reframing not only softens the blow of criticism but also clarifies our intentions and goals.

When we listen to others’ criticisms, discerning the underlying commitment can be equally enlightening. It helps in understanding their values and what they deeply care about. This practice not only reduces the negativity in conversations but also fosters a more profound understanding and connection.

2. Turning Criticism into a Request

Charlie Pellerin’s approach, as detailed in “How NASA Builds Teams,” complements the first method by converting criticism into a request. This technique is particularly practical and action-oriented. It moves the conversation from what’s not working to what can be done to improve the situation.

For example, rather than criticizing a team member for missing deadlines, a leader can make a specific request, such as asking for regular updates or a revised timeline that is more realistic. This method not only provides clear direction but also empowers the other person to take actionable steps towards improvement.

At home, this approach can be a game-changer, as I’ve personally experienced. Transforming criticism into requests within family dynamics fosters a more supportive and understanding environment. It helps in clearly communicating needs and expectations without resorting to negative criticism.

The Impact of These Approaches in Leadership and Communication

Adopting these methods can have a profound impact on leadership and communication styles. It aligns closely with the ideals of empathy, understanding, and effective leadership. By focusing on commitments and requests, leaders can create a more positive, proactive, and goal-oriented culture.

Building a Positive Culture

Transforming criticism into commitment and requests contributes to building a positive and constructive work culture. It encourages openness, transparency, and clarity in communication, reducing misunderstandings and conflict.

Enhancing Team Performance

When leaders focus on commitments and requests, it sets clear expectations and goals for the team. This clarity drives performance as team members understand exactly what is expected of them and how they can achieve it.

Fostering Personal and Professional Growth

This approach also encourages personal and professional growth. By focusing on what can be improved rather than what is wrong, individuals are more likely to be receptive to feedback and take proactive steps towards self-improvement.

Encouraging Collaborative Problem-Solving

Turning criticism into a request opens the door to collaborative problem-solving. It invites team members to be part of the solution, fostering a sense of ownership and engagement.


The transformation of criticism into commitments and requests is not just a linguistic exercise; it’s a mindset shift. It requires us to look beyond the surface level of problems and criticisms and delve into the deeper values and objectives that drive them. This approach is not only more constructive but also more in line with the principles of effective leadership and communication.

As leaders, we have the opportunity to model this behavior and set a tone that promotes growth, collaboration, and positive change. By adopting these methods, we can foster environments where open, constructive communication is the norm, and where every challenge is viewed as an opportunity for improvement and innovation.

This journey of transforming our language and approach can be challenging, but the rewards are immense. It leads to stronger relationships, more effective teams, and a culture where everyone feels valued and understood. Let’s embrace this path and witness the transformation it brings to our organizations and personal lives.

Related Posts:

Criticism Leads to a Vicious Cycle

Regrettable Leadership

Reach your next peak

We help leaders expand the change they want to see in their teams, organizations, and the wider world.